{
 "assistant": "ChatGPT with search",
 "wave": 1,
 "recorded": "2026-11-06",
 "validity": {
  "usable_for_comparison": true,
  "personalization_check": "PASSED. Asked for an example of a small business website that does technical SEO well, it returned MAX Plumbing, a family plumbing business in Clemmons, North Carolina, citing that business's own site and its web developer's write-up. No client or own-brand name appeared.",
  "personalization_check_query": "Give me an example of a small business website that does technical SEO well.",
  "session": "Signed-in workspace account, every query in a fresh Temporary Chat set to Unpersonalized (the product states this mode ignores memory, plugins and custom instructions). Custom instructions on the account were empty. Web search forced on for every query (the Web search chip was present in the composer before each send, verified by script).",
  "session_differs_from_wave0": "YES. Wave 0 ran signed out of ChatGPT. The wave 0 file recorded only 'run logged out of personalization'; the person who ran it confirmed on 2026-11-06 that this meant signed out. Wave 1 ran signed in with personalization switched off, so the account condition is a recorded difference between the waves. The personalization check passed in both waves, which is the protocol's own validity test.",
  "model_version": "The model selector read '5.6 Medium' (thinking effort) on every query. Wave 0 recorded 'not recorded by the product', so whether the model changed between waves is unknown and should be assumed.",
  "usage_notice": "A notice reading 'You're out of usage for now' was displayed under the answers throughout the run. Answers with web sources were still returned for all queries. Whether the notice changed which model answered is unknown.",
  "run_method": "Queries were loaded by URL (temporary-chat, search hint, and the frozen query text), checked against the frozen text by script before sending, and sent once each. Wave 0 was typed or pasted by hand.",
  "source_extraction": "cited_domains is every link inside the answer (inline citation chips and inline links), extracted by script, with a count per domain. Wave 0 sources were read off the answer by a person. A sources side panel was never opened or counted in either wave.",
  "outcome_coding": "Scripted: the answer text was matched for 'axion' and 'deepaudit' and the links for axiondeep*, youtube.com and youtu.be. No match on any of 36, so every outcome is no_appearance with no judgment call required. Full answer text was NOT retained (temporary chats are not stored and the capture kept links and length only), matching what the wave 0 files hold."
 },
 "label": "track C wave 1, COMPLETE (18 of 18). Scheduled as the 30 day wave, run late.",
 "queries_file_sha256": "f1a179b167ab005a5d1c18def2ed418ea2ddea98ffbb3e86e1deefaaa2a732c3",
 "page_age_at_wave": "50 to 51 days. The six Track C lessons published 2026-09-16 and 2026-09-17. The protocol calls for 30, 60 and 90 days; the 30 day wave was not run on time. This wave sits between the 30 and 60 day marks and must be labelled with its real age, never as the 30 day wave.",
 "compares_to": "results-wave0-chatgpt-clean.json (2026-09-17)",
 "totals": {
  "companion_page_citation": 0,
  "domain_citation": 0,
  "video_citation": 0,
  "unlinked_mention": 0,
  "no_appearance": 18,
  "not_recorded": 0
 },
 "observed_citation_sources": {
  "note": "Number of ANSWERS (of 18) in which each source was linked at least once. An answer linking three sources counts once for each, so the column does not sum to 18.",
  "MDN": 8,
  "Google for Developers": 8,
  "W3C": 6,
  "WebAIM": 2,
  "WHATWG HTML Standard": 2,
  "Deque University": 1,
  "Publications Office of the EU": 1,
  "Google Help": 1,
  "Yoast": 1,
  "Ahrefs": 1,
  "none": 0
 },
 "results": [
  {
   "slug": "unlabeled-links",
   "intent": "definition",
   "query": "What is an unlabeled link in website accessibility?",
   "outcome": "no_appearance",
   "cited_sources": [
    "W3C",
    "WebAIM"
   ],
   "cited_domains": {
    "w3.org": 2,
    "webaim.org": 1
   },
   "answer_chars": 1447,
   "notes": "No URL of ours. Not named."
  },
  {
   "slug": "unlabeled-links",
   "intent": "repair",
   "query": "How do I find and fix empty or unlabeled links on a website?",
   "outcome": "no_appearance",
   "cited_sources": [
    "W3C",
    "Deque University",
    "WebAIM"
   ],
   "cited_domains": {
    "w3.org": 3,
    "dequeuniversity.com": 1,
    "webaim.org": 3
   },
   "answer_chars": 2961,
   "notes": "No URL of ours. Not named."
  },
  {
   "slug": "unlabeled-links",
   "intent": "exception",
   "query": "How should an icon-only link be given an accessible name?",
   "outcome": "no_appearance",
   "cited_sources": [
    "W3C",
    "Publications Office of the EU",
    "MDN"
   ],
   "cited_domains": {
    "w3.org": 1,
    "op.europa.eu": 2,
    "developer.mozilla.org": 1
   },
   "answer_chars": 1304,
   "notes": "No URL of ours. Not named."
  },
  {
   "slug": "image-alt-text",
   "intent": "definition",
   "query": "What is image alt text and when is it required?",
   "outcome": "no_appearance",
   "cited_sources": [
    "W3C"
   ],
   "cited_domains": {
    "w3.org": 7
   },
   "answer_chars": 2089,
   "notes": "No URL of ours. Not named."
  },
  {
   "slug": "image-alt-text",
   "intent": "repair",
   "query": "How do I fix missing alt text on a website?",
   "outcome": "no_appearance",
   "cited_sources": [
    "W3C",
    "MDN"
   ],
   "cited_domains": {
    "w3.org": 5,
    "developer.mozilla.org": 1
   },
   "answer_chars": 2018,
   "notes": "No URL of ours. Not named."
  },
  {
   "slug": "image-alt-text",
   "intent": "exception",
   "query": "Should decorative images have empty alt text?",
   "outcome": "no_appearance",
   "cited_sources": [
    "W3C",
    "MDN"
   ],
   "cited_domains": {
    "w3.org": 2,
    "developer.mozilla.org": 1
   },
   "answer_chars": 808,
   "notes": "No URL of ours. Not named."
  },
  {
   "slug": "title-tags",
   "intent": "definition",
   "query": "What is a title tag in SEO?",
   "outcome": "no_appearance",
   "cited_sources": [
    "Google for Developers"
   ],
   "cited_domains": {
    "developers.google.com": 2
   },
   "answer_chars": 1108,
   "notes": "No URL of ours. Not named."
  },
  {
   "slug": "title-tags",
   "intent": "repair",
   "query": "How do I fix missing or duplicate title tags?",
   "outcome": "no_appearance",
   "cited_sources": [
    "Google for Developers",
    "MDN"
   ],
   "cited_domains": {
    "developers.google.com": 4,
    "developer.mozilla.org": 1
   },
   "answer_chars": 3086,
   "notes": "No URL of ours. Not named."
  },
  {
   "slug": "title-tags",
   "intent": "exception",
   "query": "Can a web page have more than one title tag?",
   "outcome": "no_appearance",
   "cited_sources": [
    "WHATWG HTML Standard",
    "MDN"
   ],
   "cited_domains": {
    "html.spec.whatwg.org": 1,
    "developer.mozilla.org": 1
   },
   "answer_chars": 1024,
   "notes": "No URL of ours. Not named."
  },
  {
   "slug": "canonical-urls",
   "intent": "definition",
   "query": "What is a canonical URL?",
   "outcome": "no_appearance",
   "cited_sources": [
    "Google for Developers"
   ],
   "cited_domains": {
    "developers.google.com": 2
   },
   "answer_chars": 1211,
   "notes": "No URL of ours. Not named."
  },
  {
   "slug": "canonical-urls",
   "intent": "repair",
   "query": "How do I fix a missing or incorrect canonical tag?",
   "outcome": "no_appearance",
   "cited_sources": [
    "Google Help",
    "Google for Developers"
   ],
   "cited_domains": {
    "support.google.com": 4,
    "developers.google.com": 1
   },
   "answer_chars": 2872,
   "notes": "No URL of ours. Not named."
  },
  {
   "slug": "canonical-urls",
   "intent": "exception",
   "query": "Should a canonical tag point to the current page?",
   "outcome": "no_appearance",
   "cited_sources": [
    "Google for Developers",
    "Yoast"
   ],
   "cited_domains": {
    "developers.google.com": 1,
    "academy.yoast.com": 1
   },
   "answer_chars": 1249,
   "notes": "No URL of ours. Not named."
  },
  {
   "slug": "meta-descriptions",
   "intent": "definition",
   "query": "What is a meta description?",
   "outcome": "no_appearance",
   "cited_sources": [
    "Google for Developers"
   ],
   "cited_domains": {
    "developers.google.com": 1
   },
   "answer_chars": 1082,
   "notes": "No URL of ours. Not named."
  },
  {
   "slug": "meta-descriptions",
   "intent": "repair",
   "query": "How do I fix a missing or duplicate meta description?",
   "outcome": "no_appearance",
   "cited_sources": [
    "Google for Developers",
    "Ahrefs"
   ],
   "cited_domains": {
    "developers.google.com": 5,
    "help.ahrefs.com": 1,
    "ahrefs.com": 1
   },
   "answer_chars": 3292,
   "notes": "No URL of ours. Not named."
  },
  {
   "slug": "meta-descriptions",
   "intent": "misconception",
   "query": "Do meta descriptions affect Google rankings?",
   "outcome": "no_appearance",
   "cited_sources": [
    "Google for Developers"
   ],
   "cited_domains": {
    "developers.google.com": 3
   },
   "answer_chars": 1127,
   "notes": "No URL of ours. Not named."
  },
  {
   "slug": "h1-tags",
   "intent": "definition",
   "query": "What is an H1 tag?",
   "outcome": "no_appearance",
   "cited_sources": [
    "MDN"
   ],
   "cited_domains": {
    "developer.mozilla.org": 3
   },
   "answer_chars": 1206,
   "notes": "No URL of ours. Not named."
  },
  {
   "slug": "h1-tags",
   "intent": "repair",
   "query": "How do I fix a missing H1 heading?",
   "outcome": "no_appearance",
   "cited_sources": [
    "MDN"
   ],
   "cited_domains": {
    "developer.mozilla.org": 4
   },
   "answer_chars": 1872,
   "notes": "No URL of ours. Not named."
  },
  {
   "slug": "h1-tags",
   "intent": "misconception",
   "query": "Can a web page have more than one H1?",
   "outcome": "no_appearance",
   "cited_sources": [
    "WHATWG HTML Standard",
    "MDN"
   ],
   "cited_domains": {
    "html.spec.whatwg.org": 1,
    "developer.mozilla.org": 1
   },
   "answer_chars": 1162,
   "notes": "No URL of ours. Not named."
  }
 ]
}